Update: AITA for refusing to babysit my sisters kids for several weeks while she is on a ‘babymoon’ with her boyfriend

Family dynamics can sometimes take a turn for the toxic, and when entitlement comes into play, situations can escalate quickly. Is standing firm against unreasonable demands selfish, or is it about holding someone accountable for their choices?

That’s the dilemma OP (Original Poster) faced when her sister Jamie, who had previously demanded OP babysit her three children while she went on a “babymoon,” retaliated after OP refused. Jamie, having spent nearly all her money on the trip, not only insisted OP reimburse her but also demanded she fund a Disney vacation and buy expensive baby supplies.

When OP blocked Jamie’s messages, Jamie escalated further by showing up at OP’s house at midnight—dropping off her 11-year-old daughter, Melanie, unannounced. Now, OP is left wondering whether she should call the police for child abandonment or try to handle the situation herself.

‘Update: AITA for refusing to babysit my sisters kids for several weeks while she is on a ‘babymoon’ with her boyfriend’

Expert Analysis:

When family members impose on each other, it can be frustrating. But when they go as far as abandoning a child to force a situation, legal intervention becomes a necessary discussion.

What Constitutes Child Abandonment?

Attorney Lisa Feldman, a specialist in family law, explains, “Leaving a child at someone’s home without their consent, especially in a situation where prior refusal was given, can constitute abandonment. In many jurisdictions, this is grounds for law enforcement involvement.”

Jamie not only ignored OP’s boundaries but also placed her child in a precarious position without a care for her well-being.

Why OP Is Not Obligated to Take Responsibility

Dr. Michael Carter, an expert in family relationships, states, “Being related does not mean you must accept undue burdens. Caregiving is a responsibility that should be mutually agreed upon, not forced.”

Jamie’s belief that OP should fund her lifestyle and take care of her children without discussion showcases a profound lack of accountability.

The Importance of Setting Legal Boundaries

Therapist Dr. Rebecca Hayes advises, “When someone continues to push past boundaries, refusing to acknowledge your ‘no,’ legal action may be the only way to get them to stop.”

OP now has to consider if letting Jamie get away with this will set a precedent for future neglectful behavior.

How to Handle a Family Member Who Abandons Their Child

Immediate Contact – OP should text Jamie and demand she pick up her daughter within a strict time frame.
Document Everything – Screenshots, messages, and security footage (if available) should be saved for legal protection.
Call Child Protective Services – If Jamie refuses to take responsibility, authorities should be alerted.
Reach Out to the Child’s Other Parent – If the father has custody rights, he needs to be made aware.
Consider Legal Protection – A restraining order or official complaint may be necessary if Jamie continues her behavior.