My MIL (64 F) wants me (34 F) to change the name of my business (maiden name) to their surname. How to soften the blow?

A Reddit user shared her dilemma about her mother-in-law’s insistence on renaming her successful cosmetic surgery practice to reflect the in-laws’ surname. Despite the user’s business flourishing under her maiden name and her deep connection to it, family pressure is mounting. Read the original story below.

‘ My MIL (64 F) wants me (34 F) to change the name of my business (maiden name) to their surname. How to soften the blow?’

I (34F) am a cosmetic surgeon and I opened my practice last year. It’s been doing very well and I’m doing the planning now to open another branch at a neighboring state which is my in-laws’ state.

My husband comes from a well-to-do family (grandfather was wealthy) whereas my parents were immigrants and had to get their masters here again while already having a PhD from my home country. I barely saw my parents growing up so that they could house and feed us. My practice has both my mom and dad’s last names.

My husband is a great guy and his family is very nice but they value different things and have weird priorities. I wanted a small wedding in the US because I had another reception in my parent’s home country. MIL offered to pay for a larger wedding so that they can invite more of their friends but I stuck to the 50 people limit (which is a lot I wanted 30 at the beginning)

because I wanted people my husband and I both knew AND loved to be there. I didn’t want my MIL’s stylist, her business partner or their family lawyer to attend. She eventually complied and kept meddling occasionally from then on. I never changed my last name but would unofficially be referred to Mrs husb’s last name.

At work I still use my name to not confuse my staff and patients but also to honor my dad for everything he has done all my life. Now that I’m opening another practice MIL wants me to use the family name as the brand. I told her it would create confusion and people might not know it was mine.

I built a lot of trust, patronage and recognition using my brand so I don’t want to keep correcting people and to start from the bottom in a sense. It makes perfect sense and is the smart decision business-wise. There’s also some legal and extra paperwork to be done if I used a different name.

She said she is so proud of me and wants to show me off and also her family name is very famous around here so I might get more patients. She also joked that she should get some royalty for that too. Their surname is an old American name that back in the day used to do bad things (ie c**ruption and more).

I do not want to use that name. I am south east asian, my staff are diverse and it’s something I am proud of since we do focus on ethnic and cultural esthetics instead of the generic white/european esthetics.

Im walking on eggshells here and i plan to let my husband deal with her. They always do a family dinner and I see her maybe once every 2 weeks and she always brings this up. Recently 2 of my SILs have been pestering me to do it too.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

UsuallyWrite2 −  You don’t need to soften the blow. There is no “blow”. You’re not doing anything to them. “I will not be changing my company name and I’m done discussing it.”

SighsAndSins −  Don’t do it. You built the reputation of your business all in your own. You are honoring your parents with the name for all of their sacrifice. Just tell them you will not entertain any discussion about a name change. If they pester, start avoiding going to go see them.

nic_lama −  I have a doctor friend, and when she married, I asked her whether she was going to change her last name. Her response to me also applies here: “ why would I do that? My husband didn’t go to medical school. I did.”

BelmontIncident −  If you’re trying to keep things from getting more emotionally intense, I’d suggest repeating that it’s a business decision and that your existing branding isn’t just well known, it’s known for a specific market niche. People already try to find you and you want that to be easy.

SnooAdvice2768 −  Dont do it. If your husband ia ok with it, leave it to him to handle the specifics. Regarding people pressuring you on behalf of MIL- when they can pay you for your degree and your hard work, then they can talk. You are proud of your accomplishments as you should be, and for your dad and mom who did a lot for you.

You really dont bave to answer to anyone for your work. Also finding it strange that MIL needs you to change the name of your business for her to brag about it… she can brag about it otherwise also. Its not illegal if she does the bragging and you have your maiden name and your parents names on the business.

I think its her way of controlling the narrative and making it so that THEY supported you in the expansion of the business and one upping your parents- which is as stupid as it sounds.

r_coefficient −  What blow? It’s your *name*. None of her business.. “Lol no” is a long enough answer.

IndySkyes −  This is such a weird flex from MIL. It’s not her name, she took it on at some point. So the fame etc is not hers, just vicariously. Offer to add her maiden name to the mix, lol

Pretty_Little_Mind −  Your MIL is massively overstepping. Your husband needs to shut her and her ego down. It’s ridiculous that it’s gotten to this point.

hybrid0404 −  Don’t do it. I’m married to a physician who established herself professionally with her maiden name, she didn’t change it for the exact reasons you’re describing about your business. Listen to your gut and keep it. Where is your husband at in all of this? Is he supporting you because it would probably be better coming from him.

Your MIL sounds generally meddling and it is best that your husband deals with it because if too much of it is coming from you it can make this more adversarial. I would just be direct and dispassionate, as you said “I built a brand and that brand is <maiden name , I plan to expand that brand and not start over.”

Ok_Imagination_1107 −  I don’t like the sound of your mother-in-law whatsoever, and don’t walk on eggshells – be tough about this. You must keep your brand name unchanged. And here is something to think on: Well your marriage seems great and wonderful now many of them do end in divorce.

What would happen if you had to stand in front of a judge and explain why you should have 100% share of a business that had your husband’s surname on it that you would agree to change? Would you be asked to prove that your husband had an input anytime or money into the business? Well that might not seem like a likely outcome to you It could actually happen.

How would you navigate a situation where personal values and family expectations clash in a professional setting? Should the user stand firm on her decision or find a middle ground? Share your thoughts below!