AITAH for suing a coworker?

Office pranks can sometimes add a spark of playfulness to the workday—so long as they stay harmless. But what happens when a seemingly innocent joke takes a costly turn? That’s exactly what one employee discovered after finding superglue in all the wrong places. Instead of a good laugh, he ended up with a damaged keyboard and a tense standoff with both his coworker and management.

Gone are the days when pranks meant a silly note or rearranged desk items. Now, our narrator faces the frustrating aftermath of someone tampering with a personal (and pricey) piece of equipment. After demanding a proper replacement, he learns that not everyone in the office wants to take his side. Let’s see how it all went down—and what lessons might emerge from this sticky situation.

‘ AITAH for suing a coworker?’

Expert Opinion

Let’s begin by acknowledging a basic truth: office “pranks” can either boost morale or create serious conflict, depending on how far they go. “Humor in the workplace must never cross the line into damaging personal property,” says Dr. Andrea Bonior, a psychologist interviewed in Psychology Today. Once that line is crossed, trust erodes—especially if management fails to address the wrongdoing fairly.

In this scenario, the coworker’s act of supergluing keyboard keys isn’t just inconvenient; it’s destructive. Dr. Bonior points out that pranks should remain “lighthearted, respectful, and free of real harm.” Damaging someone’s personal device goes beyond playful mischief. For many employees, items like keyboards aren’t mere accessories—they’re crucial productivity tools chosen for comfort or specialized functions. Seeing them ruined can spark immediate anger and a sense of betrayal.

Another critical angle here is the response from management. According to Dr. Bonior, the workplace should have clear guidelines on respectful conduct, including what’s off-limits. By urging the OP to accept a cheaper replacement, management essentially dismisses the seriousness of this prank. That can send a worrisome message: as long as you say “sorry,” it’s okay to damage someone else’s belongings. This environment can breed tension and discourage employees from bringing personal property in the first place.

Moreover, the notion of threatening an employee’s job security over seeking legal recourse suggests a broader HR dilemma. No employee should feel coerced into absorbing financial losses or emotional distress for fear of retribution at work. Dr. Bonior stresses that fairness, respect, and the freedom to address personal harm are foundational. If the OP’s team disregards these principles, it places them at risk for both morale and potential legal complications down the road.

Ultimately, accountability is vital for maintaining a healthy office culture. A sincere apology is a start, but it must be backed by genuine amends—like replacing the damaged item with a comparable model. Failing that, employees may justifiably explore other options. As Dr. Bonior concludes, “A supportive workplace acknowledges that actions have consequences.” If those consequences remain unclear or trivialized, pranks can quickly become toxic.

Lets dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Online reactions showed a strong consensus that the coworker’s “prank” was unacceptable, especially because it damaged expensive personal property. Many felt that simply offering a cheaper keyboard was not a real solution—nor was it fair for management to brush off the complaint. A few commenters warned that the boss’s warning about legal action raised red flags, and advised the OP to carefully document everything, since intimidation over seeking restitution could signal deeper workplace issues.

Sometimes, the line between a harmless joke and an infuriating violation can be surprisingly thin. Should the OP accept a low-quality replacement or fight for the real cost of his damaged gear? What would you do if a coworker’s “prank” ruined your belongings? Share your stories, thoughts, and advice below!