AITA for refusing to pay for thousands for something my child broke?
Open houses can be exciting for prospective buyers, but they also come with an unspoken understanding: respect the homeowner’s property. However, what happens when a child accidentally breaks something during a viewing? Is it on the homeowner for leaving fragile items out, or the parents for not keeping a closer watch?
OP and her husband were attending an open house when their four-year-old daughter wandered off and accidentally cracked a mask-like object left out in the open. Embarrassed, OP quickly left without mentioning the incident. Later, a mutual acquaintance informed the homeowner, who then demanded payment for the broken item—at a price OP found outrageous.
Now, OP is questioning whether she truly owes anything, arguing that expensive breakables shouldn’t have been left in an accessible area. But is she deflecting responsibility, or does she have a point?
‘AITA for refusing to pay for thousands for something my child broke?’
Expert Opinion:
This situation brings up key questions about responsibility, parental supervision, and property protection. While homeowners should be mindful of staging their houses appropriately for open viewings, visitors also have an obligation to ensure their children respect the space.
Understanding the Core Conflict:
The primary issue revolves around accountability. According to real estate experts, open houses are typically staged to be visually appealing, but that does not mean they should be treated as child-friendly environments. Real estate agents often advise sellers to remove valuables or breakables to avoid potential damage. However, that does not absolve visitors from watching their children.
Dr. Lisa Damour, a psychologist specializing in family dynamics, states: “While it’s understandable that accidents happen, teaching children respect for others’ property and ensuring active supervision in unfamiliar spaces is crucial.”
Additionally, legal experts note that guests in a private home—even during an open house—can be held liable for damages caused by negligence. The “you break it, you buy it” principle is often applied in these situations, reinforcing that supervision is key when bringing young children into unfamiliar settings.
Expert Insights:
Dr. Alexandra Solomon, a family therapist and relationship expert, explains: “When we take our children into public or private spaces, we take on the role of being their guide and protector. If they cause damage—accidental or not—it is our duty to take responsibility rather than deflect blame.”
Additionally, research from the National Association of Realtors suggests that homeowners have the right to seek compensation for damages incurred during open houses, especially if negligence is involved.
Proposed Solutions and Takeaways:
For those attending open houses with children, here are key takeaways:
- Supervise Young Children Closely – Open houses are not designed for kids to explore freely. Keeping them nearby can prevent accidents.
- Communicate If an Accident Happens – If something is damaged, honesty goes a long way in resolving the situation fairly.
- Understand Liability – Even in an open house, guests are responsible for their actions (or their children’s), and homeowners have the right to seek compensation.
Here’s what Redditors had to say:
OP’s reluctance to take responsibility for the broken item has sparked debate. While homeowners should be cautious about what they leave on display, visitors—especially those with young children—must take extra care. Accidents happen, but accountability matters.
What do you think? Should OP pay for the damages, or was the homeowner partially at fault for leaving fragile items within reach?