AITA for not putting my husband’s name on gifts I bought on my own?

A Reddit user shared their frustration about carrying the burden of holiday gift shopping for both their family and their husband’s family. Despite repeated requests for help over the years, and even while being six months pregnant, the husband failed to contribute to gift shopping or wrapping.

Exhausted and fed up, the user decided not to include her husband’s name on the presents she bought, leading to a disagreement where he accused her of making him look bad. Was her decision petty, or was it a reasonable way to express her frustration? Read the full story below.

‘ AITA for not putting my husband’s name on gifts I bought on my own?’

I (27f) have been married to my husband (29m) for 3 years and we’ve been together since we were 18 and 19. The first 2 years we had been together, when we were still pretty young and our relationship was new, we bought Christmas gifts separately (except in some rare cases). But when we got pretty serious, we started making gifts from the both of us to other people. Since then, he has not once helped me buy the gifts. That includes gifts for my family, our friends, but even gifts for his family.

Occasionally, he would give me some ideas as to what the person would want, but that was still pretty rare and the ideas he gave were most of the time very vague. And even when he gave me ideas, I was the one that bought the gifts and went Christmas shopping alone.

I was fine with it at the beginning as I really enjoyed gift giving and finding the perfect ideas for everyone, but it’s been 8 years of this and it’s getting pretty exhausting. I’ve also evolved in my career since we got together, and now have way less free time to spend buying gifts.

So last year I asked before the holiday season if he could help this year and we’d each buy some of the presents. Out of maybe 20 people we bought gifts for, he bought only one. And he told me that he would “take care of it” until the very last minute but eventually forgot, so I had to buy his sister and mother a present less than 24h before Christmas. After that, I told him that I now expected help because this could not happen again as it was mentally and physically exhausting for me.

So this year I bought half of the gifts and he was supposed to buy the other half. He didn’t. Yesterday I spent 7 hours at the mall trying to find the rest of the gifts and he was no help. I sometimes called him to ask if the person would like a gift, if they already had it, or what he thought and he mostly said “I don’t know”, “maybe” and “whatever”. I also have to add that I’m 6 months pregnant so this was extremely exhausting.

When I got home I was angry and tired and while wrapping the presents I decided that since he didn’t help at all I wouldn’t put his name on the presents. Usually we write something like “from Mary and John” (not our real names), but I just wrote “from Mary”.

Today as we were packing all the gifts in the car to go to his parents’s house he noticed that his name wasn’t on it. I explained it to him and said that he didn’t help so he didn’t get credit for what I bought. He keeps saying that it’s unfair and that I’m gonna make him look bad, and asks that I change it. I don’t know if I should.

Maybe this is petty but I don’t know what else to do. I’ve asked for help many times and I’m just afraid he’s never going to change. Should I put his name? Am I mean for this? How can I make him understand how much I need help?

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

wrathofworlds −  NTA, I just wouldn’t buy them. Make sure your family is sorted and let him explain it to his.

MedicinalWalnuts −  NTA. You’ve been carrying this responsibility for him for far too long and have gotten far too resentful for it to be healthy. Next year, you will have the additional responsibility of a child, in addition to the one you married. From my perspective, the best solution is to stop wasting hours shopping at the mall and just give people a combo token gift/gift card combination. Examples: set of wineglasses and a bottle of wine, a box of movie snacks with DVDs or movie tickets, a baseball cap with tickets to a game, etc.

Gift giving should NOT be this stressful, expensive, or time consuming. If your husband has opted out, just make it easy on yourself by taking the approach I just suggested. As long as you choose things the person likes, it is a thoughtful gift. And it is enough.

LeamhAish −  NTA He’s acting like a child, and you’re acting like his mom. A mom takes a kid to the mall last minute to shop for gifts. The mom decides what gifts to buy. The mom wraps the gifts. The mom then writes the child’s name on the gift. Stop treating him like a child, and let him suffer the consequences of his own actions like a grown man. The humiliation should get him sooner or later, and unlike the gifts, only his name belongs on the guilt. Not yours.

Maximum-Bobcat-6250 −  NTA- he should be embarrassed. He’s your partner and you asked for help and he refused. Maybe it will take his family having just your name on the gifts to make him realize he needs to put some effort in. We are similar here except we’ve been married 11 years. This year I flat out didn’t buy for anyone in his family (except my niece and nephew because they’re kids and it felt mean not to) and I told him he had to do it.

It’s Dec 22 and I know he bought nothing. So we will show up empty handed and if anyone says anything I’ll flat out tell them it was my husbands turn this year to buy gifts. It’s not even about actually giving a gift, it’s about how these men can’t seem to put effort into anyone or anything else that doesn’t interest them. My husband has no problem spending time and effort doing things that benefit him, but has no time to do things for others and I’m sick of it.

kleinmona −  I have a simple rule. I do my family. He does his family. If he is not getting anything – well. Sit down at the table, wait until the gift exchange starts and when he is not able to provide anything, just drop the following line: ‘Honey, we agreed that you take care of your family and I take care of mine. I didn’t buy anything.’ And don’t say SORRY (!) – he didn’t do his job not you!

Yes it will be Very Uncomfortable- feel free to grab a card, write a few lines (sorry that John didn’t buy you anything – I had a very bad feeling, but he really needs to understand that he has to take responsibility. I would like to invite you to a nice brunch/lunch/coffee… just the two of us. ) and have that ready in your purse. Hand it over when you leave! In a way that John doesn’t see it.

Im VERY sure that a lot of females will start taking your side – because a LOT of men behave this way!. One important side note here: I have the feeling that boys/men are always ’excused’ of the gift thing. And it starts YOUNG! So they don’t get the ‘hints’ that people are dropping. Im still ‘teaching’ my husband to read those. And he gets better… but this ‘if you don’t do it, I will stress myself and fix it for you’ just enables John.

Grilled_Cheese10 −  I’m older (59f) and it took some realization on my part just how much I just took on the “female jobs” role when I got married without even thinking about it. Like you, OP, I just did it all. I figured out what to get, shopped, wrapped it, did all of it, for mine and my husband’s whole family. I sent all the cards, birthday gifts, all of it, all year. I had a full-time job and kids, but I did it all.

Then after one of my brothers got married he sent me a birthday card. He sent it. It was his writing. He addressed it. My very first thought when I got it was, “I wonder why his wife didn’t do this?” AND I STOPPED MYSELF IN MID-THOUGHT and asked myself what the hell was wrong with me.

He somehow managed to handle all of this stuff before he got married, why in anyone’s world would these jobs be magically transferred to the female because they got married? Stand your ground. If there are no gifts on Christmas Day you say, “[husband’s name] was in charge of that.” And make it clear to him that IS what is going to happen if he doesn’t take care of it.

mom_in_the_garden −  NTA. Honey, you need to allow your man to experience natural consequences. First, make it crystal clear which gifts he’s responsible for. His friends and adult family is a good place to start. I leave out children, because they shouldn’t be disappointed while he is learning self sufficiency in gift buying. Two weeks before the occasion, ask what he’s purchased for his parents.

When you get that blank stare, remind him that the lines won’t be getting shorter and he’d better get on it. When he comes to you in a panic the weekend before the event, calmly commiserate and say, “I’m glad I won’t be the one fighting the crowds,” and go back to whatever you were doing. When there is no gift for one of his relatives, look at him in wide eyed surprise and say, “I thought you were taking care of gifts for your family this year.”

MerlinBiggs −  NTA. OMG! Your 6 months pregnant and he’s leaving all the work and stress of buying presents to you! Leave his name off, and if anyone mentions it tell them exactly why. Let’s see what his family have to say about leaving all that to the 6 months pregnant mother of his child.

Ali–625 −  NTA. Maybe being embarrassed in front of his family when they question why his name isn’t on the gifts (please, if they ask, tell them the truth before he can chip in and make something up that will make him sound like the victim) is just the kick up the backside he needs to stop being lazy and expecting you to run around after him.

QuirkySyrup55947 −  I have stopped buying gifts for my husband’s friends and family because of this. If they don’t get anything… too bad. I remind him a few times, and then I just stop caring.